The Kuleshov Effect: Is Batman Hungry?

A while back I had game AI expert Dave Mark on my podcast. One of the things he talked about in the context of using psychology to shape player behavior was the Kuleshov effect. I wanted to look at this topic in detail.

The effect is named after a Soviet filmmaker of the the same name, who created mini-montages and showed that the content of one shot could change the viewer’s perception of another. Imagine you have four small clips of film. One shows a man staring blankly into the camera. Another shows a bowl of soup. A third shows a sexy lady. The last shows a dead child. Actually, you don’t have to imagine. Here are clips similar to what Kuleshov used, all strung together:

Now, take three groups of people. Show one group just the shot of the soup followed by the shot of the man staring into the camera. Show another group just the sexy lady followed by the shot of the man. Finally, show the third group just dead child followed by the man.

Now ask everyone to describe what the man in the clip is thinking.

What researchers have found1 is that people’s perceptions of the man in the shot are greatly influenced by the context created by the other clip. Supposedly, those who saw the soup were more likely to say that the man looked hungry. Those who saw the woman reported a lascivious look in the man’s eye. And those who saw the dead child reported seeing that the man’s expression bent to sorrow. When faced with an ambiguous situation or stimulus we immediately lean on contextual information for guidance on what information to attend to, how to interpret it, and even what we remember. In my mind this also relates to what’s called the fundamental attribution error, which describes how we tend to blame internal states for the behaviors of others, as opposed to external factors. For example, “That person is crossing her arms because she’s unfriendly; we’re crossing our arms because we’re cold.” When contextual information supports this bias, it’s even more likely to be used to make sense of an ambiguous situation.

dark souls

As in film, the Kuleshov effect and the fundamental attribution error can be leveraged by game designers to add a little depth to their world. And the best part is that it can often be the players themselves who are creating the backstories, justifications, and narratives. If you’re playing an open world game and you come across two NPCs having a chat in town, that’s just background decoration. But find the same NPCs with the same animations and chatter while exploring the woods outside of town? What’s up with that? They up to something nefarious? Scandalous? The answer could emerge out of the player’s situation –whether she found them there at night, while there are enemies about, or while on a mission to hunt animals. It could be different every time.

We also see this come up a lot in games like those in the Dark Souls series. Why are these creatures here at this particular location, in possession of these particular items? Little details create bigger contexts, which impel players to make up their own minds. And sometimes that’s even more fun.

Batman-Kuleshov

And sometimes it’s hilarious. I recently played Batman: Arkham Knight and noticed the Kuleshov effect in action. At several points when Batman has a conversation with an NP, he takes on an expression much like the man in Kuleshov’s clips above. The Bats is just dead eyed, expressionless, and stares into the middle distance while the firefighter he just rescued earnestly thanks him for saving the day. This happens over and over, and I soon started believing my own narrative, that Batman was just a hair’s breadth from flipping out. He was seconds away from buckling under all the pressure, all the Scarecrow toxin, and the general, overwhelming hell that is his life. He was just ready to snap and break that firefighter in half at any second. This was aided by the context of Arkham Knight’s storyline, and that situation with Batman and the firefighter suddenly got a lot more tense.

All because of a blank stare.

Supporting me on Patreon helps ensure that new articles and podcasts are available for everybody.

Footnotes:

1. For example, Mobbs, D. et al. (2006). The Kuleshov Effect: the influence of contextual framing on emotional attributions. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 1(2). 95-106.

10 thoughts on “The Kuleshov Effect: Is Batman Hungry?

  1. I’m curious about the Dark Souls comment. Is that something non-gamers say more than gamers?

    As a gamer Loot is Loot. It’s “guarded” or “held” by enemies because that’s what the designers wanted to put there. Unless there’s literally a story reason (get magic stone from evil wizard), it’s purely a design choice, and making up a story for it, even subconsciously, is literally making stuff up out of nothing

    I wonder if this sort of thinking unconsciously fuels the Anita Sarkessian type of “Games are bad and affect everyone to do bad stuff” ideology.

    • Loot is definitely used as contextual storytelling in Dark Souls. Do a search for “Dark Souls Lore” on Youtube and you’ll get lots of examples/explanations.

      • That was a search I’d never have thought of and lots of interesting theories as well. I still don’t understand, but that’s just me not being any good at psychology questions. Some people can’t do maths, I give wrong psychology answers.

        I’ll shut up now, I don’t have anything to offer to the discussion.

        • Psychology is not so much a mystery as you may consider ” Innocent Bystander “.

          I have taught myself much on the subject of psychology by reading articles such as this, fallowing sources listed in Wikipedia, speaking with others, analyzing my own metal activities, reading downloaded PDF books, and even watching YouTube videos on a particular related aspect. By gathering information from every useful source, I developed a broader view. Grading myself by my own comprehension, there was no need for an authority to dictate fact from fiction. If the conclusions did not stand to reality, then they were false or inconclusive. either way, more study was always a requirement due to new questions or verification of previous answers.

          I have taught myself more in shorter time by the mere necessity of comprehension, Ad to this , personal interest and the experience becomes both fun and educational without a soul to degrade my efforts by condemning my current deductions that inevitably lead me to more study and knowledge.

          🙂

          It is difficult to flunk a person when they are not bound by a standardized grading system 😉

  2. Pingback: 9/28/15 – Developers, Tutorials, Emotions, UI fat, and Morals | Game Design Digest

  3. Pingback: Karnawał Blogowy #22 - Bobrownia

  4. Pingback: This Week in Video Game Blogging: Remastering for HD and MOBA Map Analysisgamedev.fm | gamedev.fm

  5. Pingback: This Week in Video Game Blogging: Remastering for HD and MOBA Map Analysis - GeekTechTalk

  6. Pingback: Undertale: Using Comedy and Fantasy to Include Outsiders - Cliqist

Leave a comment