DJ Jazzy Contrast – The Contrast Effect and DJ Hero Renegade

Why did Activision take an already expensive game and release an even MORE expensive version without adding a whole lot to it? And what does it have to do with “Ozark wild mushrooms served with a brandy demi glaze?” I’ve got an idea. Let me share it with you.

As you may know, DJ Hero, a relatively new rhythm game from Activision and FreeStyleGames, includes its own controller in the form of a fake plastic turntable. Many gamers thought that the initial price tag of $120 was high, but were outright boggled by the $200 –TWO HUNDRED DOLLAR!– list price on the special “Renegade” collector’s edition that only had a few paltry perks relative to the base model. Why would Activision take an already expensive game and put out an even MORE expensive version? 1


$200? Ehh....

They’re stupid? Nope. According to one recent press release, DJ Hero was 2009’s highest grossing new video game IP. So something worked. 2 At the very least, the Renegade Edition pricing is an example of what economists call “price targeting” and what author Tim Harford likens to getting turkeys to vote in favor of thanksgiving. 3 In essence, Activision is putting the Renegade Edition out there so that people who are cavalier about price self-identify themselves and allow themselves to be sold basically the same product for more money. It’s the same trick restaurants use to find patrons willing to pay more for food when they charge an extra $.80 for a slice of cheese on your burger when it really only costs them a few cents.

But I don’t think that’s the whole story. I think there’s something called “the contrast effect” at work, and I think Eminim and Jay-Z would be appalled.

You may remember the contrast effect from my discussion how the cover art for Borderlands might have gotten approved. Basically it’s a cognitive bias that kicks in when focusing on the magnitude of one bit of information affects your perception of another piece of information. Like a colored tie appearing brighter when it’s contrasted against a white shirt. Here’s an extremely simple example where the same color of gray looks lighter or darker depending on the background it’s contrasted against:

Simple contrast effect

Which circle is lighter? Trick question! They're the same.

This is why I think the Renegade Edition of DJ Hero was put out there: to activate the contrast effect and to make the regular, $120 edition look cheaper in comparison. Man, $200 for a video game? Forget that. I’m gonna be a the smart shopper and only buy the $120 version. What restraint I have! Quick! Somebody congratulate me!

This kind of thing is done to you EVERYWHERE around you, as the following quote from a New York Times story on the science of restaurant menu writing illustrates:

Some restaurants use what researchers call decoys. For example, they may place a really expensive item at the top of the menu, so that other dishes look more reasonably priced; research shows that diners tend to order neither the most nor least expensive items, drifting toward the middle. Or restaurants might play up a profitable dish by using more appetizing adjectives and placing it next to a less profitable dish with less description so the contrast entices the diner to order the profitable dish.”

Those “Ozark wild mushrooms served with a brandy demi glaze” may be the most expensive side dish listed, but the restaurant only listed them first so that the cheaper mashed potatoes, which have a higher profit margin, look more appealing.

If you’re like me, you see attempts at the anchoring effect everywhere once you know about it. Now that you know about it, think back on the last time you saw a regular version of a game advertised next to the collector’s edition. Does the regular one seem so cheap now?


1. DJ Hero Renegade photo credit: j.reed on
2. But as Joystiq points out, that’s not the same as “most profitable”
3. Harford, T. (2006). The Undercover Economist. Oxford: University Press.

13 thoughts on “DJ Jazzy Contrast – The Contrast Effect and DJ Hero Renegade

  1. first of all,very nice you have here,love it!
    and i agree,thats is the reason why i opted to buy a 16 gig 3gs iphone instead of 32 gig!you articles are spot on!

  2. I think Modern Warfare 2 is an even better example, as they had 3 editions, thus a middle tier. I wonder if they sold more of the higher margin mid range version due to the existence of a super high end ‘prestige’ edition.

  3. I’ve been checking this blog regularly since I’ve first read about it on Joystiq and I really can’t explain how informative and enlightening your posts are.

    But isn’t it strange for someone to go for the “middle/most profitable for the seller” option, even if they know they are being “played”? Sometimes, the joy you get out of the slight upgrade can make the price look logical, or is it just an illusion?

  4. @ Forrest
    Yeah, but what I think makes this work so well with DJ Hero is that people’s price expectations aren’t anchored on the $60 price point. Usually that’s what people contrast against for CEs and such, but it’s not applicable to this thing.

    Thanks, glad you’re digging it! The thing about humans is that we all assign subjective values to things, so yeah, maybe paying a little more for a bigger screen or getting your gadget in black yields enough pleasure to make the extra money worth it. This is what drives economists crazy.

  5. I always knew this as the Goldilocks effect. One product priced too high, one priced too low (therefore it must be an awful product by default) and one priced moderately in the middle with the other two making it look more reasonable.

    Apple seem to do this a lot.

    Yours is a good point well made though!

  6. A very fun (i.e. dastardly) manipulation of this effect can be seen at many gas pumps.

    Knowing that people default to the “middle” choice, many gas pumps arrange them from left to right


    Totally illogical, but i bet it catches a ton of people.

  7. Pingback: Anchoring Plus Scarcity « c# to javascript, actionscript

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.